Kristin Davis Beat Hilary Swank forMelrose PlaceRole: ‘She Obviously Went on to Win 2 Oscars’ (Exclusive)

Mar. 15, 2025

(L) Kristin Davis and Hilary Swank.Photo:Arnold Jerocki/WireImage; Daniele Venturelli/Getty

Arnold Jerocki/WireImage; Daniele Venturelli/Getty

Kristin Daviswent head-to-head withHilary Swankfor her iconic role onMelrose Place.

“It was Hilary Swank, myself and a girl named Meredith,” Davis says of the final auditions forAaron Spelling’s series. “It was us three who tested for Brooke, and I think they must have read like 500 girls.”

(L-R) Heather Locklear, Kristin Davis, Andrew Shue and Grant Show on ‘Melrose Place’.Paramount Television/ Courtesy Everett

Paramount Television/ Courtesy Everett

At the time,Melrose Place’s leading lady,Heather Locklear, had gotten married toRichie Samborain a “lace, halter gown,” so Davis bought a bustier reminiscent of the wedding dress in an effort to showcase a similar sense of sexuality.

“I had this whole plan that I was going to strip my jacket off in the scene,” she laughs. “I did it, and clearly it worked out. But I mean, I was just riddled with anxiety, okay?”

Davis also recalls feeling self conscious about her “very, very long hair” and debated cutting it as none of the women on the show had long locks. Eventually, she talked herself out of changing her appearance.

“I remember going in, and it was just the three of us, and everyone was very nice,” she says. “It wasn’t one of those like scary room, and then you go in one at a time. And I remember Hilary came out, and she seemed so young, and she had kind of shorter hair and kind of sporty, and I was like, ‘Uh-oh.’ And then Meredith had longer hair also. I was like, ‘Oh, good.'”

Hilary Swank.Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty

Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty

When Swank finished her audition, Davis says the actress was dejected and claimed, “I totally blew it,” despite their best efforts to comfort her.

“Obviously she goes on to win two Oscars,” Davis laughs. “She did fine. She did fine.”

Though she had the opportunity to audition, the actress says her agent at the time didn’t think she would get the job because of her appearance.

“I had a really good talk with her way back, where she said to me, ‘Kristin, you know, I really need to apologize because I was your agent when they were starting to cast Brooke, and I didn’t submit you for it, because I didn’t think you were hot enough,'” she recalls.

Kristin Davis.Eugene Gologursky/Getty

Eugene Gologursky/Getty

While the honesty was shocking to hear, Davis says she appreciated her candor and her effort to make amends.

“Obviously she was wrong, but I wasn’t like the look,” she continues, admitting that she could see where her former agent was coming from. “I wasn’t the hot look of the ’90s. I had hips, I had curves. You were supposed to be straight in the ’90s with some boobs.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“Now, I was only slightly aware of that because of my 12 auditions a day. It would be me and a bunch of like model-looking girls,” she explains. “And sometimes I’d get the part, because I could speak, and they maybe couldn’t speak so well.”

“It was scary,” she said of a dating-nightmare in one episode. “I’m usually very careful and do not talk about my private life, but here I am in this situation where I’ve started a podcast about the themes of our show.”

source: people.com