Married at First SightRecap: Season 16 Alum Jasmine Secrest Reveals Which Couple Is Missing a 'Key Ingredient' for Success

Mar. 15, 2025

Jasmine Secrest.Photo:Courtesy Jasmine Secrest

Courtesy Jasmine Secrest

Jasmine Secrest appeared on season 16 ofMarried at First Sight, which took place in Nashville in 2023. Jasmine and Airris Williams ended their marriage over not seeing eye to eye about sex. On Oct. 15, season 18 ofMarried at First Sightpremiered on Lifetime, returning to Chicago to follow five couples as the reality of their newlywed lives together sets in. Here, Jasmine gives PEOPLE her recap of the Dec. 10 episode.

This episode hadeverything—emotions were running high, triggers were pulled, and my heart was in my throat more times than I can count. But amidst all the drama, one thing was clear: the dynamics of these couples hitwaytoo close to home. Watching them navigate their ups and downs felt like re-living moments from my own time on the show. Let’s dive in, shall we?

Ikechi & Emem: Stuck in Their Feelings

From left: Emem and Ikechi on ‘Married at First Sight’.Mood Photo & Video

Mood Photo & Video

Ikechi and Emem’s storyline? It’s like watching two peoplereallyinvested in each other, but missing the key ingredient: communication. Sure, emotions are intense, but there’s a whole lot of room for growth in how theytalkto each other.

Take Emem’s family, for example. They clearly care about her and want the best, but their concerns were delivered in a way that left a lot to be desired. They could’ve been more tactful, but let’s be honest, Ikechi’s pride isn’t helping either. Instead of opening up, he goes into defensive mode, giving off a “take it or leave it” vibe. And when Emem’s cousin tried to speak some truth into him? Ikechi didn’t take that opportunity to explain himself—he just closed off. It’s like watching someone drown in their own pride.

At the core of it all, Ikechi is clearly uncertain about the marriage, but instead of owning that, he’s deflecting and playing the blame game. If he could just admit where he stands, the whole thing would probably take a turn for the better. But hey, we all struggle with facing tough truths sometimes, right?

Camille & Thomas: Communication Goals

From left: Camille and Thomas on ‘Married at First Sight’.Mood Photo & Video

Can we just say it? Camille and Thomas are couple goals. This pair is giving us a masterclass in communication. Everything they do—how they express themselves, how they listen—is a reminder that relationships require effort, but also tons of respect.

Sure, Camille’s a bit of a nitpicker (we’ve all been there), but she’s direct, honest, and thoughtful in how she shares her feelings. And Thomas? He doesn’t shut down when Camille opens up; instead, he listens, absorbs, and reacts with maturity. Now, Thomas might not always have therightwords when communicating (hey, we’ve all been there), but he always tries his best to make sure Camille feels heard and understood.

That effort? It speaks volumes.Their dynamic is great. It’s one thing to communicate, but it’s another to do it in a way that’s so warm and authentic. I can’t help but root for these two. If they keep this up, I can see them going the distance—seriously, they’re setting the bar high.

Juan & Carla: The Affection Gap

From left: Karla and Juan.Yosmaira Ochoa Photography

Yosmaira Ochoa Photography

Now, let’s dive into Juan and Carla. I really feel for Carla here, especially when it comes to affection. I can totally relate to her. It wasn’t until I was on the show myself that I realized how much I crave affection from my partner—and when it’s not there, it really hits hard.

Carla’s love language is clearly affection, but Juan just doesn’t seem to be on the same page, especially when it comes to public displays of affection. I don’t fault Juan for this—everyone has their own comfort zones. But I do wish he would be more upfront with Carla about where he stands. Instead of letting the tension build; an open, honest conversation could really clear the air.

Juan is definitely trying to be there for Carla in other ways, but until they address this affection gap, I’m afraid the couple might stay stuck in a holding pattern. Sometimes it’s the hard conversations that make all the difference.

Michelle & David: Are They In or Out?

From left: Michelle and David on ‘Married at First Sight’.Misha Media Photography

Misha Media Photography

Okay, Michelle and David? I’m struggling here. I can’t tell if David is genuinely trying to make this marriage work or if he’s just doing it for the cameras. Sometimes he shows a little spark, but then I get this vibe that he’s more about playing the role of a husband than actuallybeingone. It’s like he’s more concerned with his image than the relationship itself.

On the flip side, Michelle seems to have already checked out. You can see it in her eyes—she’s almost waiting for a reason to bail, and yet… there’s this moment when David mentions working out with Madison, andbam—she’s visibly bothered. Which makes me think:If you’ve already mentally checked out, why let that bother you?

There’s definitely some back-and-forth energy happening here, and honestly, it’s hard to tell where they’re headed. Both of them seem like they’re playing their own games, and I’m not sure what’s going to snap them out of it.

Madison & Allen: Forcing Something That Isn’t There

From left: Madison and Allen on ‘Married at First Sight’.Mood Photo & Video

Lastly, Madison and Allen. Yikes. Honestly, I don’t think this is the right fit for either of them. They’re both nice people, but it feels like they’re trying to fit into a relationship mold that just doesn’t work for them. It’s like trying to force a puzzle piece into the wrong slot—it’s not working, no matter how much they try.

I feel for them both because they’re clearly trying, but you can see that something’s just off. And then there’s that group activity moment where Allen totally checked out—he didn’t participate in something Madison put a lot of effort into. That was a major red flag. If you’re not showing up for the small stuff, how can you show up for the bigger things? It’s a tough situation, but it’s clear they’re both struggling to find common ground.

In the end, this episode was a whirlwind. So many emotions, so many moments that made me think, “Whoa, I’ve been there.” Relationships are hard, y’all, but if there’s one thing we can all take away from these couples, it’s that communication is crucial.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

source: people.com