The Best Black Tights We Tested for Rip-Resistance and Comfort

Mar. 15, 2025

In This ArticleView AllIn This ArticleOur Top PicksReviewsWhat to KnowBehind the ScenesWhy Trust PEOPLE?What Is PEOPLE Tested?

In This ArticleView All

In This Article

View All

Our Top Picks

Reviews

What to Know

Behind the Scenes

Why Trust PEOPLE?

What Is PEOPLE Tested?

Photo:People

People

The quest for theperfectblack tights can be an overwhelming one. Whether you’re looking forshapewear-inspiredtights or a pair offleece-lined onesthat’ll keep you cozy during the cold weather months, black tights are a must-have for your wardrobe.

Experts Say“I love how tights can elevate a look from basic to chic while adding warmth,” says NYC-based personal stylistAdrian Causing. “They also extend your wardrobe, transitioning pieces from spring to fall, and fall to winter.”

Experts Say

“I love how tights can elevate a look from basic to chic while adding warmth,” says NYC-based personal stylistAdrian Causing. “They also extend your wardrobe, transitioning pieces from spring to fall, and fall to winter.”

Keep reading to find out which brands we named the best black tights.

Our Top PicksBest Overall:Hue Blackout Tights with Control Top at Amazon$18Jump to ReviewBest Overall, Runner-up:Sheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights at Sheertex.comJump to ReviewBest Budget:EVERSWE Soft Opaque Tights at Amazon$9Jump to ReviewBest Budget, Runner-up:Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights at Walmart$13Jump to ReviewBest Stretch:Snag Semi-Opaque Tights at Snagtights.usJump to ReviewBest Rip-resistant:SALESpanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End Tights at Amazon$70$50Jump to ReviewBest Semi-Opaque:Calzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights at Calzedonia.comJump to ReviewBest Sheer:Commando Sexy Sheer Tights at Amazon$40Jump to ReviewBest Splurge:SALEWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 Tights at Amazon$55$41Jump to ReviewBest Tall:A New Day Blackout Tights at Target$9Jump to Review

Best Overall:Hue Blackout Tights with Control Top at Amazon$18Jump to ReviewBest Overall, Runner-up:Sheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights at Sheertex.comJump to ReviewBest Budget:EVERSWE Soft Opaque Tights at Amazon$9Jump to ReviewBest Budget, Runner-up:Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights at Walmart$13Jump to ReviewBest Stretch:Snag Semi-Opaque Tights at Snagtights.usJump to ReviewBest Rip-resistant:SALESpanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End Tights at Amazon$70$50Jump to ReviewBest Semi-Opaque:Calzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights at Calzedonia.comJump to ReviewBest Sheer:Commando Sexy Sheer Tights at Amazon$40Jump to ReviewBest Splurge:SALEWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 Tights at Amazon$55$41Jump to ReviewBest Tall:A New Day Blackout Tights at Target$9Jump to Review

Best Overall:Hue Blackout Tights with Control Top at Amazon$18Jump to Review

Best Overall:Hue Blackout Tights with Control Top at Amazon$18

Best Overall:

Best Overall, Runner-up:Sheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights at Sheertex.comJump to Review

Best Overall, Runner-up:Sheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights at Sheertex.com

Best Overall, Runner-up:

Best Budget:EVERSWE Soft Opaque Tights at Amazon$9Jump to Review

Best Budget:EVERSWE Soft Opaque Tights at Amazon$9

Best Budget:

Best Budget, Runner-up:Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights at Walmart$13Jump to Review

Best Budget, Runner-up:Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights at Walmart$13

Best Budget, Runner-up:

Best Stretch:Snag Semi-Opaque Tights at Snagtights.usJump to Review

Best Stretch:Snag Semi-Opaque Tights at Snagtights.us

Best Stretch:

Best Rip-resistant:SALESpanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End Tights at Amazon$70$50Jump to Review

Best Rip-resistant:SALESpanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End Tights at Amazon$70$50

Best Rip-resistant:

SALE

Best Semi-Opaque:Calzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights at Calzedonia.comJump to Review

Best Semi-Opaque:Calzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights at Calzedonia.com

Best Semi-Opaque:

Best Sheer:Commando Sexy Sheer Tights at Amazon$40Jump to Review

Best Sheer:Commando Sexy Sheer Tights at Amazon$40

Best Sheer:

Best Splurge:SALEWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 Tights at Amazon$55$41Jump to Review

Best Splurge:SALEWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 Tights at Amazon$55$41

Best Splurge:

Best Tall:A New Day Blackout Tights at Target$9Jump to Review

Best Tall:A New Day Blackout Tights at Target$9

Best Tall:

Best OverallHue Blackout Tights with Control TopPHOTO: Hue$18 at AmazonView on Hue.com$19 at BloomingdalesStar QualitiesDelivered top performance in our lab’s snag, rip, and stretch testsThick yet comfortable with fuller coverage for warmthComfortable, supportive waistbandRed FlagsStrictly for opaque tights loversHue Blackout Control Top tights are our best overall pick, having earned a perfect five out of five on our testing rubric. Across the board they performed excellently in terms of stretch, comfort, durability, and value. They offer the comfort and support ofworkout leggings, with the lightweight feel of pantyhose. They’re perfect for layering in colder months for extra warmth or if you’re seeking more coverage.The thick, stretchy control top waistband was compressive but still super comfortable. These tights stretched easily but always regained their original shape afterward. We were impressed with how durable they proved to be. Jewelry couldn’t snag or rip them. Only the nimble (small finger blade) eventually ripped them.We didn’t have any issues with these tights. The only drawback might be if someone prefers a sheerer look than these blackout tights that offer minimal skin visibility. For comfortable tights that hold up to wear and literal tear for less than $20, they’re hard to beat.Sizes:1-5 |Materials:Nylon, spandex |Finish:Opaque |Rise:High | Care: Hand wash in cold water, drip dryPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best OverallHue Blackout Tights with Control TopPHOTO: Hue$18 at AmazonView on Hue.com$19 at Bloomingdales

Best OverallHue Blackout Tights with Control Top

Best Overall

Hue Blackout Tights with Control Top

PHOTO: Hue

$18 at AmazonView on Hue.com$19 at Bloomingdales

Star QualitiesDelivered top performance in our lab’s snag, rip, and stretch testsThick yet comfortable with fuller coverage for warmthComfortable, supportive waistbandRed FlagsStrictly for opaque tights lovers

Star QualitiesDelivered top performance in our lab’s snag, rip, and stretch testsThick yet comfortable with fuller coverage for warmthComfortable, supportive waistband

Delivered top performance in our lab’s snag, rip, and stretch tests

Thick yet comfortable with fuller coverage for warmth

Comfortable, supportive waistband

Red FlagsStrictly for opaque tights lovers

Strictly for opaque tights lovers

Hue Blackout Control Top tights are our best overall pick, having earned a perfect five out of five on our testing rubric. Across the board they performed excellently in terms of stretch, comfort, durability, and value. They offer the comfort and support ofworkout leggings, with the lightweight feel of pantyhose. They’re perfect for layering in colder months for extra warmth or if you’re seeking more coverage.

The thick, stretchy control top waistband was compressive but still super comfortable. These tights stretched easily but always regained their original shape afterward. We were impressed with how durable they proved to be. Jewelry couldn’t snag or rip them. Only the nimble (small finger blade) eventually ripped them.

We didn’t have any issues with these tights. The only drawback might be if someone prefers a sheerer look than these blackout tights that offer minimal skin visibility. For comfortable tights that hold up to wear and literal tear for less than $20, they’re hard to beat.

Sizes:1-5 |Materials:Nylon, spandex |Finish:Opaque |Rise:High | Care: Hand wash in cold water, drip dry

PHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best Overall, Runner-upSheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist TightsPHOTO: SheertexView on Sheertex.com

Best Overall, Runner-upSheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights

Best Overall, Runner-up

Sheertex Classic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights

PHOTO: Sheertex

View on Sheertex.com

Star QualitiesStretchy and easy-to-wear90-day guarantee from ripsInclusive size rangeRed FlagsThough rip-resistant, can snag and pill

Star QualitiesStretchy and easy-to-wear90-day guarantee from ripsInclusive size range

Stretchy and easy-to-wear

90-day guarantee from rips

Inclusive size range

Red FlagsThough rip-resistant, can snag and pill

Though rip-resistant, can snag and pill

These tights offer utility and comfort, with an impressive stretch capacity and a thick 6.5-inch comfort control top band for support. With a 90-day guarantee against rips, they’re perfect for those with pets and kids who want more durability from a pair of tights.

We love that it has an inclusive size range that goes up to 3X, and the company’s focus on sustainability. The fact these tights are machine washableandcan be machine-dried (which is nearly unheard of for hosiery) make it one of our favorite pairs.

Sizes:XS-XXL |Materials:Nylon, polyethylene, spandex |Finish:Semi-opaque |Rise:High |Care:Machine wash cold, tumble dry low

PHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Did your size sell out?Try theClassic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights. It’s similar to our best overall, runner up, but with a smaller waist band. Same rip-resistance, same durability, same great value.

Did your size sell out?

Try theClassic Sheer Rip-Resist Tights. It’s similar to our best overall, runner up, but with a smaller waist band. Same rip-resistance, same durability, same great value.

Best BudgetEVERSWE Soft Opaque TightsPHOTO: Amazon$9$8 at Amazon

Best BudgetEVERSWE Soft Opaque Tights

Best Budget

EVERSWE Soft Opaque Tights

PHOTO: Amazon

$9$8 at Amazon

Extremely stretchy yet retained original shape

Durable and run-resistent

Flexible waistband designed for comfort and ease

Red FlagsWaistband is narrower than some of our other picks

Waistband is narrower than some of our other picks

These opaque tights from Everswe are our most affordable pick at just under $8, offering durability and comfort for roughly the cost of your favorite specialty latte. With a variety of fun colors, they’re a great pick if you’re also looking for other colored tights with minimal investment.

We loved how soft and easy these tights were to wear. The waistband is highly stretchy, accommodating fluctuating waistlines, though we wish it were thicker than 1.5 inches. These tights passed our durability tests, retaining their shape after overstretching and only showing small holes from the finger blade.

Despite that, they remained run-resistant, which is truly impressive. They’re a reliable, budget-friendly addition to any closet.

Sizes:S/M, L/XL, 2XL/3XL |Materials:Polyamide, spandex |Finish:Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Machine wash

Best Budget, Runner-upHanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque TightsPHOTO: Hanes$13 at WalmartView on Hanes.comStar QualitiesWaistband was comfortable, not constrictiveLight compression provided shaping and kept the tights in placePetite-friendly lengthAffordable price pointRed FlagsLooked more semi-opaque then opaque when wearingWaistband is thinner and smaller than others we testedOur runner-up for the best budget-friendly pick are these smoothing opaque tights from Hanes. At just $14, Hanes delivers comfy, durable tights that live up to the brand’s trusted reputation.During testing, these tights were easy to put on and comfortable to wear. They felt smooth and soft against the skin, with a stretchy yet subtly compressive fit. The waistband — although thinner than some other waistbands we tested — stretched easily while maintaining its shape, and the tights remained comfortable.Small snags occurred during lab tests with jewelry and small blades, but they were minimal. While marketed as opaque, we found the tights to be more semi-opaque, leaving us unsure how well they’d actually conceal cellulite (as claimed). They’re a solid, affordable option especially for someone who needs petite sizes.Sizes:AB, CD, EF, GH, IJ |Materials:Nylon, spandex |Finish:Semi-Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash onlyPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best Budget, Runner-upHanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque TightsPHOTO: Hanes$13 at WalmartView on Hanes.com

Best Budget, Runner-upHanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights

Best Budget, Runner-up

Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights

PHOTO: Hanes

$13 at WalmartView on Hanes.com

Star QualitiesWaistband was comfortable, not constrictiveLight compression provided shaping and kept the tights in placePetite-friendly lengthAffordable price pointRed FlagsLooked more semi-opaque then opaque when wearingWaistband is thinner and smaller than others we tested

Star QualitiesWaistband was comfortable, not constrictiveLight compression provided shaping and kept the tights in placePetite-friendly lengthAffordable price point

Waistband was comfortable, not constrictive

Light compression provided shaping and kept the tights in place

Petite-friendly length

Affordable price point

Red FlagsLooked more semi-opaque then opaque when wearingWaistband is thinner and smaller than others we tested

Looked more semi-opaque then opaque when wearing

Waistband is thinner and smaller than others we tested

Our runner-up for the best budget-friendly pick are these smoothing opaque tights from Hanes. At just $14, Hanes delivers comfy, durable tights that live up to the brand’s trusted reputation.

During testing, these tights were easy to put on and comfortable to wear. They felt smooth and soft against the skin, with a stretchy yet subtly compressive fit. The waistband — although thinner than some other waistbands we tested — stretched easily while maintaining its shape, and the tights remained comfortable.

Small snags occurred during lab tests with jewelry and small blades, but they were minimal. While marketed as opaque, we found the tights to be more semi-opaque, leaving us unsure how well they’d actually conceal cellulite (as claimed). They’re a solid, affordable option especially for someone who needs petite sizes.

Sizes:AB, CD, EF, GH, IJ |Materials:Nylon, spandex |Finish:Semi-Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash only

PHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best StretchSnag Semi-Opaque TightsPHOTO: SnagView on Snagtights.usStar QualitiesHighly stretchy from waistband to footCan fit a wide range of sizes and heightsSoft, legging-like feelSturdy and snag-resistentRed FlagsDidn’t retain shape as well after stretching as other tights we testedOur pick for black tights with the best stretch is size-inclusive clothing brand Snag’s Semi-Opaque 50 Denier tights. These were unparalleled in stretch during our tests. They stretched in every direction from waistband to foot, making them ideal for a variety of body shapes and heights.These tights were super soft and comfortable, feeling more like leggings than traditional tights, in the best way. They resisted snagging or tearing when tested with sharp jewelry. While small tears occurred with the finger blade, they impressed with their durability for everyday wear.We found these tights didn’t hold their shape as effectively as some others when we overstretched them for testing purposes, but it was nothing a simple wash and dry won’t fix. These will become your new favorite, comfortable go-to tights for any occasion.Sizes:A/B, C, D, E, Short F, F, G  |Materials:Polyamide, elastane, cotton |Finish:Semi-opaque  |Rise:Mid |Care:Hand wash or use a lingerie bag to protect, squeeze dryPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best StretchSnag Semi-Opaque TightsPHOTO: SnagView on Snagtights.us

Best StretchSnag Semi-Opaque Tights

Best Stretch

Snag Semi-Opaque Tights

PHOTO: Snag

View on Snagtights.us

Star QualitiesHighly stretchy from waistband to footCan fit a wide range of sizes and heightsSoft, legging-like feelSturdy and snag-resistentRed FlagsDidn’t retain shape as well after stretching as other tights we tested

Star QualitiesHighly stretchy from waistband to footCan fit a wide range of sizes and heightsSoft, legging-like feelSturdy and snag-resistent

Highly stretchy from waistband to foot

Can fit a wide range of sizes and heights

Soft, legging-like feel

Sturdy and snag-resistent

Red FlagsDidn’t retain shape as well after stretching as other tights we tested

Didn’t retain shape as well after stretching as other tights we tested

Our pick for black tights with the best stretch is size-inclusive clothing brand Snag’s Semi-Opaque 50 Denier tights. These were unparalleled in stretch during our tests. They stretched in every direction from waistband to foot, making them ideal for a variety of body shapes and heights.

These tights were super soft and comfortable, feeling more like leggings than traditional tights, in the best way. They resisted snagging or tearing when tested with sharp jewelry. While small tears occurred with the finger blade, they impressed with their durability for everyday wear.

We found these tights didn’t hold their shape as effectively as some others when we overstretched them for testing purposes, but it was nothing a simple wash and dry won’t fix. These will become your new favorite, comfortable go-to tights for any occasion.

Sizes:A/B, C, D, E, Short F, F, G  |Materials:Polyamide, elastane, cotton |Finish:Semi-opaque  |Rise:Mid |Care:Hand wash or use a lingerie bag to protect, squeeze dry

Best Rip-resistantSpanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End TightsPHOTO: Spanx$70$50 at Amazon$38 at Nordstrom$38 at Spanx

Best Rip-resistantSpanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End Tights

Best Rip-resistant

Spanx SPANXshape High-Waisted Tight-End Tights

PHOTO: Spanx

$70$50 at Amazon$38 at Nordstrom$38 at Spanx

Star QualitiesDidn’t snag or tear when tested with sharp jewelry or fingernailsWhen ripped with finger blade, didn’t run like others we testedFirm, supportive, yet still comfortable fitThicker than others we tested, perfect for warmth or fuller coverageRed FlagsMight be too long for some petite sizes

Star QualitiesDidn’t snag or tear when tested with sharp jewelry or fingernailsWhen ripped with finger blade, didn’t run like others we testedFirm, supportive, yet still comfortable fitThicker than others we tested, perfect for warmth or fuller coverage

Didn’t snag or tear when tested with sharp jewelry or fingernails

When ripped with finger blade, didn’t run like others we tested

Firm, supportive, yet still comfortable fit

Thicker than others we tested, perfect for warmth or fuller coverage

Red FlagsMight be too long for some petite sizes

Might be too long for some petite sizes

Snags or runs don’t stand a chance with these tights from celeb-loved andPEOPLE Tested brand Spanx. They proved to be our most rip-resistent pair through both rounds of testing. Sharp rings and finger nails couldn’t make a dent in these tights. Even when using the small finger blade it took multiple tries and extra effort to achieve a true rip. We were impressed how, even after finally being torn, these tights still didn’t run like others.

Our only issue was that our petite-sized testers found them harder to bunch and put on. But if you need tights that can endure everything from daily wear to your pet’s claws, these are the ones for you.

Sizes:A-E |Materials:Nylon, elastane|Finish:Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash warm, line dry

Best Semi-OpaqueCalzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch TightsPHOTO: CalzedoniaView on Calzedonia.comStar QualitiesAchieves ideal semi-opacity when wearingSupportive, firm waistbandSoft and pleasant on the skinResistant to most snags or tears during testingRed FlagsRuns quickly formed when rippedDidn’t retain its original shape as well as othersThis pair fromceleb-worn brand Calzedoniais our favorite for the perfect semi-opaque finish. When it comes to opacity, Causing recommends 50 denier “which should be everyone’s staple.” The tights offer a subtle translucence for an elegant look while still maintaining some coverage, bringing just the right amount of sheerness to any outfit.These tights stretched easily during testing though they didn’t maintain their shape as well as some of our other picks. The soft material felt great on our skin, and the waistband was firm and provided more support while still remaining comfy when wearing.This pair proved durable, standing up to sharp objects during testing. Though mostly tear-resistant, a hole from the finger blade caused a run to spread.Sizes:XS/S, M, L, XL  |Materials:Polyamide, elastane |Finish:Semi-Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Machine wash cold, line dryPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeopleWhat Is Denier?Denier refers to the density or thickness of fiber/fabric, so when we refer to denier of tights, we’re talking about how sheer they are. The higher the denier, the more opaque the tights will look. Causing recommends a 50 denier as a versatile option.

Best Semi-OpaqueCalzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch TightsPHOTO: CalzedoniaView on Calzedonia.com

Best Semi-OpaqueCalzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights

Best Semi-Opaque

Calzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights

PHOTO: Calzedonia

View on Calzedonia.com

Star QualitiesAchieves ideal semi-opacity when wearingSupportive, firm waistbandSoft and pleasant on the skinResistant to most snags or tears during testingRed FlagsRuns quickly formed when rippedDidn’t retain its original shape as well as others

Star QualitiesAchieves ideal semi-opacity when wearingSupportive, firm waistbandSoft and pleasant on the skinResistant to most snags or tears during testing

Achieves ideal semi-opacity when wearing

Supportive, firm waistband

Soft and pleasant on the skin

Resistant to most snags or tears during testing

Red FlagsRuns quickly formed when rippedDidn’t retain its original shape as well as others

Runs quickly formed when ripped

Didn’t retain its original shape as well as others

This pair fromceleb-worn brand Calzedoniais our favorite for the perfect semi-opaque finish. When it comes to opacity, Causing recommends 50 denier “which should be everyone’s staple.” The tights offer a subtle translucence for an elegant look while still maintaining some coverage, bringing just the right amount of sheerness to any outfit.

These tights stretched easily during testing though they didn’t maintain their shape as well as some of our other picks. The soft material felt great on our skin, and the waistband was firm and provided more support while still remaining comfy when wearing.

This pair proved durable, standing up to sharp objects during testing. Though mostly tear-resistant, a hole from the finger blade caused a run to spread.

Sizes:XS/S, M, L, XL  |Materials:Polyamide, elastane |Finish:Semi-Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Machine wash cold, line dry

What Is Denier?Denier refers to the density or thickness of fiber/fabric, so when we refer to denier of tights, we’re talking about how sheer they are. The higher the denier, the more opaque the tights will look. Causing recommends a 50 denier as a versatile option.

What Is Denier?

Denier refers to the density or thickness of fiber/fabric, so when we refer to denier of tights, we’re talking about how sheer they are. The higher the denier, the more opaque the tights will look. Causing recommends a 50 denier as a versatile option.

Best SheerCommando Sexy Sheer TightsPHOTO: Amazon$40 at Amazon$40 at NordstromView on Wearcommando.comStar QualitiesCan double as lingerieSmooth finishSupportive and comfortable high-rise waistbandRed FlagsThin fabric more prone to holes and snagsIf you’re looking for a sheer option that can double as lingerie, your search ends with these Commando tights. They give just the right peek of skin under skirts, shorts, and dresses. The delicate sheerness of these tights really elevates any outfit. What really makes them stand out is the high-rise lace waistband that makes them feel more like lingerie than a regular pair of tights. Beyond looking beautiful, the lace waistband also offers comfort and support.While these tights are certainly a fashionable pick, they lack durability. When tested with Velcro and sharp jewelry, snags and holes were immediate and very noticeable. At their steeper price point compared to our other picks, these would be better for occasions and events than everyday wear.Sizes:S-XL |Materials:Nylon, elastane |Finish:Sheer |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash, drip dryPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best SheerCommando Sexy Sheer TightsPHOTO: Amazon$40 at Amazon$40 at NordstromView on Wearcommando.com

Best SheerCommando Sexy Sheer Tights

Best Sheer

Commando Sexy Sheer Tights

$40 at Amazon$40 at NordstromView on Wearcommando.com

Star QualitiesCan double as lingerieSmooth finishSupportive and comfortable high-rise waistbandRed FlagsThin fabric more prone to holes and snags

Star QualitiesCan double as lingerieSmooth finishSupportive and comfortable high-rise waistband

Can double as lingerie

Smooth finish

Supportive and comfortable high-rise waistband

Red FlagsThin fabric more prone to holes and snags

Thin fabric more prone to holes and snags

If you’re looking for a sheer option that can double as lingerie, your search ends with these Commando tights. They give just the right peek of skin under skirts, shorts, and dresses. The delicate sheerness of these tights really elevates any outfit. What really makes them stand out is the high-rise lace waistband that makes them feel more like lingerie than a regular pair of tights. Beyond looking beautiful, the lace waistband also offers comfort and support.

While these tights are certainly a fashionable pick, they lack durability. When tested with Velcro and sharp jewelry, snags and holes were immediate and very noticeable. At their steeper price point compared to our other picks, these would be better for occasions and events than everyday wear.

Sizes:S-XL |Materials:Nylon, elastane |Finish:Sheer |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash, drip dry

PHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best SplurgeWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 TightsPHOTO: Wolford$55$41 at Amazon$55 at NordstromView on Wolford.comStar QualitiesPremium quality fabric felt great on our skinProved quite rip-resistant during testsMaintained its shape and didn’t lose elasticityEasy to put on and stays putRed FlagsNot as easy to stretch as some of our other picksWhen torn, a run spread through the tightWolford is an iconic hosiery brand known for its high-quality materials and construction and the Velvet De Luxe tights are worth the splurge in our opinion. They not only feel luxurious but the quality shows in how well they withstood all of our durability and wear tests.These tights didn’t rip or tear when faced with sharp rings and other jewelry. It was even tough to tear with our finger blade, but we eventually created a small hole, which formed a run that spread when stretched. While this pair wasn’t as stretchy as others we tried, we appreciated how well they retained their original shape.The tights are built for long-lasting wear and will hold up over time. They slid on effortlessly, and the soft fabric was incredibly comfortable against our skin. They’re an investment that will elevate any wardrobe and are worth every penny.Sizes:XS-XL |Materials:Nylon, elastane |Finish:Semi-Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Machine was cold (gentle), line dryPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best SplurgeWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 TightsPHOTO: Wolford$55$41 at Amazon$55 at NordstromView on Wolford.com

Best SplurgeWolford Velvet de Luxe 50 Tights

Best Splurge

Wolford Velvet de Luxe 50 Tights

PHOTO: Wolford

$55$41 at Amazon$55 at NordstromView on Wolford.com

Star QualitiesPremium quality fabric felt great on our skinProved quite rip-resistant during testsMaintained its shape and didn’t lose elasticityEasy to put on and stays putRed FlagsNot as easy to stretch as some of our other picksWhen torn, a run spread through the tight

Star QualitiesPremium quality fabric felt great on our skinProved quite rip-resistant during testsMaintained its shape and didn’t lose elasticityEasy to put on and stays put

Premium quality fabric felt great on our skin

Proved quite rip-resistant during tests

Maintained its shape and didn’t lose elasticity

Easy to put on and stays put

Red FlagsNot as easy to stretch as some of our other picksWhen torn, a run spread through the tight

Not as easy to stretch as some of our other picks

When torn, a run spread through the tight

Wolford is an iconic hosiery brand known for its high-quality materials and construction and the Velvet De Luxe tights are worth the splurge in our opinion. They not only feel luxurious but the quality shows in how well they withstood all of our durability and wear tests.

These tights didn’t rip or tear when faced with sharp rings and other jewelry. It was even tough to tear with our finger blade, but we eventually created a small hole, which formed a run that spread when stretched. While this pair wasn’t as stretchy as others we tried, we appreciated how well they retained their original shape.

The tights are built for long-lasting wear and will hold up over time. They slid on effortlessly, and the soft fabric was incredibly comfortable against our skin. They’re an investment that will elevate any wardrobe and are worth every penny.

Sizes:XS-XL |Materials:Nylon, elastane |Finish:Semi-Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Machine was cold (gentle), line dry

Best TallA New Day Blackout TightsPHOTO: Target$9 at TargetView on Shipt.comView on Doordash.comStar QualitiesImpressively stretchy lengthwiseWithstood durability tests with only mild pillingReturned to original shape after stretchingRed FlagsLess stretch in the waistbandWe’ve got the new go-to black tights for long-legged folks. We observed extensive stretching in the legs of these tights. Even better, the tights returned to their original length and shape after stretching. Basically, they’re built to last.The tights withstood rubbing with Velcro, resulting in only minor pilling but no visible holes. They also stood up to sharp jewelry and nails, resisting tears or runs. At a super affordable price, these are a great value and perfect for taller people.Sizes:S/M-XL/XXL |Materials:Nylon, spandex |Finish:Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash, line dry or dry flatPHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

Best TallA New Day Blackout TightsPHOTO: Target$9 at TargetView on Shipt.comView on Doordash.com

Best TallA New Day Blackout Tights

Best Tall

A New Day Blackout Tights

PHOTO: Target

$9 at TargetView on Shipt.comView on Doordash.com

Star QualitiesImpressively stretchy lengthwiseWithstood durability tests with only mild pillingReturned to original shape after stretchingRed FlagsLess stretch in the waistband

Star QualitiesImpressively stretchy lengthwiseWithstood durability tests with only mild pillingReturned to original shape after stretching

Impressively stretchy lengthwise

Withstood durability tests with only mild pilling

Returned to original shape after stretching

Red FlagsLess stretch in the waistband

Less stretch in the waistband

We’ve got the new go-to black tights for long-legged folks. We observed extensive stretching in the legs of these tights. Even better, the tights returned to their original length and shape after stretching. Basically, they’re built to last.

The tights withstood rubbing with Velcro, resulting in only minor pilling but no visible holes. They also stood up to sharp jewelry and nails, resisting tears or runs. At a super affordable price, these are a great value and perfect for taller people.

Sizes:S/M-XL/XXL |Materials:Nylon, spandex |Finish:Opaque |Rise:High |Care:Hand wash, line dry or dry flat

PHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: PeoplePHOTO: People

What to Know About Black Tights

Denier

When purchasing your new favorite pair of black tights, Causing says to think about the sheerness (or denier). ”The spectrum goes from 5 to 100 — the larger the number, the thicker and less sheer the tights get.” Sheer tights, likeCommando Sexy Sheer Tights, can offer a sultry touch to a look, while thicker, more opaque black tights offer more coverage for those who seek it. Also, fuller coverage tights are great for warmth in the colder months.

Durability

Though durability isn’t often associated with black tights, advances in fabric technology now allow them to withstand more wear and tear than ever. It’s important to consider what level of durability you require in a pair of tights and when or where you’ll be wearing them most.

If you wear black tights regularly or are concerned about clothing waste, Causing encourages you to look for brands with high durability. Having a pet is also a big consideration. We found thatSpanx High-Waisted Tight-End Tightsstand up to claws — a big plus for pet owners.

Comfort and Fit

You want tights that look great and feel comfortable. Our top pick,Hue Blackout Tights with Control Top, excel in both. Comfort and fit depend on stretch, and personal preference plays a big role. Some prefer high-rise tights for a smoothing, secure fit, while others opt for mid-rise.

Many tights we featured offer size guides online, or you can try them on in-store. Also, consider the weight: A thick tight will feel good in the winter, but you may want to switch to a sheer tight when the weather gets warm.

People / Tamara Staples

Price

Tights run the gamut when it comes to pricing. The tights we tested range from $5 to $75, with a median price of $13. In our testing, we found that sometimes you get what you pay for, with more durable and comfortable tights coming in at a higher price range (usually around $25). We also found great budget options, like theEverswe Soft Opaque Tights, that are easier on the wallet and therefore less costly if they snag or run.

We tested a total of 41 pairs of black tights, ranging from luxury brands to Amazon finds, both in our lab and at home. After both rounds of tests were complete, we rated each pair of tights based on a one-to-five scale (five being the best) against the following testing attributes: stretch, opaqueness, durability, and value. Ultimately, the tights with the highest average ratings earned a spot on this PEOPLE Tested list.

L.A. Hubillais a contributing shopping writer for PEOPLE who specializes in fashion, beauty, and lifestyle topics. She also tests beauty and apparel products for several publications, including InStyle, and Byrdie. As a former professional dancer, she knows a thing or two about tights and is currently obsessed withthese tights from Les Belles. L.A. updated this piece with the most up-to-date information, from pricing to long-term testing insights from our PEOPLE Tested lab.

PEOPLE shopping writerAlyssa Brasciacovers beauty, home, fashion, and lifestyle topics and has also written for national and regional publications, including InStyle, Shape, and Southern Living.

Our Expert PanelAdrian Causingis a personal stylist, celebrity stylist, fashion retail professional, and print and digital stylist based in New York City.

Our Expert Panel

Adrian Causingis a personal stylist, celebrity stylist, fashion retail professional, and print and digital stylist based in New York City.

We created thePEOPLE Tested seal of approvalto help you find the very best products for your life. We use our unique methodology to test products in three labs across the country and with our network of home testers to determine their effectiveness, durability, ease of use, and so much more. Based on the results, we rate and recommend products so you can find the right one for your needs.

In short, PEOPLE Tested provides recommendations you can trust — every day, every purchase.

source: people.com